Media Reports

(U.K.) Daily Mail, Monday, November 16, 1998

Reprinted with the permission of Solo Syndication Limited, U.K.

GOVERNMENT PLANS TO RESTRICT TOBACCO
TO SPECIAL ROOMS

Cigarettes at work
likely to be stubbed out by law


By EMILY WILSON Medical Reporter

SMOKING is likely to be banned in the workplace under radical new proposals being drawn up by the Government.

Staff would be able to sue their employers if they are forced to breathe smoke while at their desk or work station.

Smoking would be allowed only in designated rooms or at outdoor workplaces, such as farms and construction sites.

Exemptions would be made for prisons, psychiatric hospitals which provide residential care and pubs, restaurants and clubs, where smoking is regarded as part of the culture.

Under the Government's White Paper on Smoking and Health, due to be published next month, these particular work places would be encouraged to sign up to voluntary codes which promise non-smoking areas and better ventilation for non-smokers and staff. Yesterday Clive Bates, director of Action on Smoking and Health, said: 'If the Government wants to stop smoking in the workplace, it's great news.

'Of course there are difficulties in workplaces which are also someone's home, such as in nursing homes, or in pubs, where there is an element of consumer choice.'

Department of Health sources say smoking at work is a key target in the Government drive to reduce tobacco-related deaths.

But Tessa Jowell, the Minister for Public Health, is acutely sensitive to accusations of nannying and has stopped short of an outright ban on smoking in all office buildings and public places. She plans to put the new White Paper proposals out to consultation, to allow businesses and smokers to comment on the changes.

Current health and safety rules on smoking are vague. They say 'effective and suitable provision should be made to ensure that every enclosed workplace is ventilated by a sufficient quantity of fresh or purified air'.

The revised codes are likely explicitly to ban smoking where people work in enclosed spaces, unless there are exemptions such as in the case of restaurants.

'Enforced passive smoking is a real invasion of civil liberties,' said Mr. Bates. 'But I don't think they're going to go for a Californian-style ban on smoking in all restaurants. It wouldn't be practical at the moment.'

The Government has also backed away from raising the age at which youngsters can buy cigarettes from 16 to 18, nor will it be introducing an outright ban on tobacco advertising, relying instead on voluntary agreements with retailers about displays.

A suggestion that will be taken up, however, is to provide free nicotine gum and patches to the poorest in society to help cut down on smoking.

A recent ICM survey found 54 per cent of people approve of smoking bans in all public places, 64 per cent back them in restaurants and bars and 80 per cent in planes, buses and trains.

Health Secretary Frank Dobson, an ex-smoker, is fiercely determined to cut the 120,000 deaths a year caused by tobacco consumption.


£129billion bill for smokers' ill-health
From IVOR KEY in New York

CIGARETTE prices are expected to rocket after America's four biggest tobacco firms agreed to pay £129billion to settle health claims.

The money will be used to pay for the past, present and future treatment of smokers suffering from lung cancer, emphysema and a host of other illnesses caused by tobacco.

But although it is the biggest legal settlement ever, some anti-smoking advocates believe the industry is getting away lightly. Under a similar Senate bill which was defeated last year, the firms -Philip Morris, R J Reynolds Tobacco, Lorillard Tobacco and Brown & Williamson - would have had to pay out over £300billion.

The four are responsible for making the top brands of cigarettes in the U.S. including Marlborough, Winston, Parliament, Lark, Camel, Virginia Slims and Merit.

The bonanza will be shared by all but four of America's 50 states over the next 25 years. The others, Minnesota, Florida, Mississippi and Texas, will get slight increases on the £25billion for which they have already settled.

The settlement provides the companies with no protection from the thousands of private lawsuits being filed. But, ironically, their stocks have been rising on Wall Street in anticipation of this deal because investors will now know exactly how much it is costing them.

Under the settlement, manufacturers will have to stop using outdoor billboards, adverts on buses and trains and selling merchandise with brand name logos, such as cartoon characters like Joe Camel. The brand names, however, will be allowed to sponsor one sporting event each per year such as Philip Morris's Virginia Slims tennis tournament and Winston's NASCAR motor races.